Teachings Library › Teachings Library

Krishnamurti and the Theosophical Society! - I AM University

Krishnamurti and the Theosophical Society! - I AM University

By Dr Joshua David Stone

To show how far this process had gone, Annie Besant announced to the Theosophical Society who seven of the chosen apostles were, of the coming descending Planetary Christ, the Lord Maitreya.

Another disconcerting event occurred in Krishna’s life when he was told by Leadbeater and Annie Besant that his brother Nitya was not going to die even though he was very ill. Some time later Nitya did die and a bit of a schism was created because of this, especially with Lead-beater, and even with the Masters on some level. He still was accepting his role as the vehicle for the Lord Maitreya, however.

During one of the major Theoshophical conventions, over 3000 people attended. Krishna spoke at the end of the conference and Lord Maitreya, for the first time was clearly felt and seen (by clairvoyants) descended into Krishnamurti as he was speaking. This was considered monumental by the Theosophical community.

Soon after, Annie Besant issue a statement to the Associated Press of America stating, "The Divine Spirit has descended once more on a man, Krishnamurti, one who, in his life is literally perfect, as those who know him can testify. The World Teacher is here."

The Theosophical Society as a whole was a very fragmented organization around the world. There seemed to be a lot of infighting, and ego battles going on. Krishna was becoming more and more conflicted, and feeling like a fish out of water. He was quoted in Mary Lutyen’s book as saying to the general secretary of the Theosophical Society for Wales, the following statement: "He told us that he had never been able to read a Theosophical book in His life - could not understand our Theosophical jargon and, although he had heard many Theosophical lectures, none of them had convinced him of their knowledge or truth."

Here was a man who had been trained by the leaders of the Theosophical movement and was representing the Ascended Masters and Their teachings and yet didn’t understand and believe in Their teachings. This, of course, was the foreshadowing of things to come.

Krishna began describing himself as having achieved "union with the beloved". The problem being that many of the people in the Theosophical Society didn’t believe he had achieved union, for his teachings were not consistent at all with the basic beliefs of the Theosophical movement.

Krishnamurti began saying things like, there was no such thing as the seven levels of initiation, or stages along the path, and even going so far as not believing in the Ascended Masters. At one point he even said he didn’t believe in God.

Krishna closed The Order of the Star. Leadbeater and Annie Besant agreed that he clearly did not have the omniscience of the Lord, and this was eventually stated in the Theosophical newspaper, as Krishnamurti resigned from the Theosophical organization and when his own way. He did not want disciples or apostles or even to be a vehicle for the Lord Maitreya.

The final blow had come when he had ordered Annie Besant to close the esoteric section of the Theosophical Society which she had done at first, but later changed her mind. When she reversed her decision is when Krishnamurti resigned. Krishnamurti did not understand or even believe in the teachings of the Ascended Masters.

His new philosophy was a rather Zen like philosophy that was very abstract and, in my personal opinion, very hard to understand. I do not mean to judge Krishnamurti, for he became a very influential world teacher in his own right in his future years, and affected an enormous number of people.

I, personally, do not relate to his later teachings, for I feel the teachings of Madame Blavatsky, Leadbeater, and later Alice Bailey material are some of the clearest teachings on the planet. Krishnamurti, however rejected all this. He was to have a great following, however, in my opinion, I think this was in large part because of how the Theosophical movement had built him up to be the next Jesus Christ.

There are many paths to God and I respect Krishnamurti’s right to follow whatever path he chooses. I also want to say in his defense, that the decision to not be the vehicle for the Lord Maitreya, was a mutual one. Lord Maitreya, seeing what was going on, mutually decided that it was not meant to be, and there was no judgment in this.

To show how far Krishnamurti went from the Theosophical Society can be seen in a quote from Mary Lutyen’s book, where Krishnamurti made the following statement to a question about the nature of God.

"We have invented God. Thought has invented God, that is we, out of misery, despair, loneliness, anxiety, have invented that thing called God. God has not made us in His image - I wish He had. Personally I have no belief in anything. The speaker only faces what is, what are facts, the realization of the nature of every fact, every thought, all the reactions. He is totally aware of all that. If you are free from fear, from sorrow, there is no need for a God."

In a later address he further considered the role of the Ascended Masters as having no objective existence. He said they were mental images shaped by belief and imagination. Leadbeater’s explanation that he gave in private was that Krishnamurti had let his personality or ego obscure his clarity.

Krishnamurti went on to discount all paths, all religions, and all spiritual organizations by saying in Mary Lutyen’s book, "I maintain that truth is a pathless land, and you cannot approach it by any path whatsoever, by any religion, by any sect. That is my point of view, and I adhere to that absolutely and unconditionally. Truth, being limitless, unconditioned, unapproachable by any path whatsoever, cannot be organized; nor should any organization be formed to lead or coerce people along any particular path."

Again, I would disagree with him on this point. I, personally don’t believe it is the path, religion, or organization that is the problem. The problem is when ego infiltrates an organization that the problem arises. It is totally possible to have a path to God that is free of ego.

To Krishnamurti’s defense on this point, I will say that the Theosophical Society was filled with ego battles to an extreme. I think, however, he was "throwing the baby out with the bath water" in making such a general all consuming statement of all religions, spiritual organiza-tions, and movements.

Krishnamurti’s place in history was quite extraordinary. Krishnamurti died in 1986 at the age of ninety. Krishnamurti, to his credit, started eight different schools in Europe, America, and India. Krishnamurti had a special interest in educating children in these schools. The single object of his teaching was to set men free from all the gates which divide man from man, such as race, religion, nationality, class and tradition.

Although his teachings may have not been completely clear of his ego and personality, he was most definitely a world teacher who influenced an enormous number of people for the positive in his talks, lectures and writings and books.

Continue reading